Midway Evaluation of Toronto Maple Leafs Defensive Unit
The Toronto Maple Leafs have experienced a rollercoaster season thus far, despite stellar performances from Auston Matthews, who is on track for a 70-goal season, and William Nylander, who is enjoying a standout year. Fans had high expectations following last season’s playoff breakthrough, yet the team finds itself in a tight race just to secure a playoff spot.
The team’s goaltending struggles have been widely discussed. Joseph Woll has been sidelined for an extended period due to an ankle injury, while Ilya Samsonov’s poor form led to him clearing waivers and being demoted to the AHL. Martin Jones has shown effort but is evidently a temporary solution at best.
Additionally, the forwards must shoulder some responsibility for the Leafs’ current standing in the league. While Matthews, Nylander, and Mitch Marner have consistently carried the team, John Tavares has seen a decline in production this season, tallying only 40 points in 51 games, a departure from his usual point-per-game pace. Furthermore, the lack of secondary scoring is evident, with Max Domi being the next highest-scoring forward with just 27 points. Expectations for players like Tyler Bertuzzi and Calle Jarnkrok have yet to materialize.
However, as has been noted since October by many observers, the biggest weakness for the Toronto Maple Leafs remains their defensive corps. Apart from Morgan Rielly, who continues to perform admirably, the rest of the defensive roster lacks players suitable for top-four NHL roles.
A closer examination of each defenseman’s contributions thus far, along with their future prospects, is necessary to assign midseason grades for each player.
