The 2024 MLB trade deadline has officially passed, and the Pirates have made significant improvements to their roster. With these changes, Derek Shelton now faces the task of assembling the most effective lineup to maximize run production.
With several new additions to the team, let’s explore how the Pirates can optimize their lineup post-trade deadline.
What is the best lineup the Pirates can create now that the MLB trade deadline has passed?
Andrew McCutchen, Designated Hitter
The ideal leadoff hitter for the Pirates is fan favorite Andrew McCutchen. While he may not be replicating his MVP-winning season, he remains highly productive when positioned at the top of the lineup.
This season, McCutchen has posted a solid .704 OPS with 13 home runs and 30 RBIs. His wRC+ stands at the league average of 100, along with an 11.8% walk rate. However, he is experiencing a career-high strikeout rate of 26.3%.
As a leadoff hitter, McCutchen has a .240 batting average with 12 home runs and 25 RBIs. His OPS in this position is .742, which includes an on-base percentage of .332 and a slugging percentage of .410. This season has demonstrated that to get the best performance from McCutchen, he needs to be in the leadoff spot.
For the Pirates to continue scoring runs effectively, McCutchen should remain at the top of the order.
