The Toronto Blue Jays underperformed in 2024, but their talent means they won’t need a complete overhaul to compete in 2025. Most of the team is staying intact as they head into the offseason, although some changes are necessary. Christopher Kline from FanSided identified Bo Bichette, Chris Bassitt, and manager John Schneider as three individuals who should not return next season.
Today, we’ll broaden that list with three more players who are unlikely to return in Toronto next year and the reasons for their departure.
For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord for insider updates as the MLB offseason approaches.
**3. RHP Dillon Tate**
The Blue Jays picked up right-handed pitcher Dillon Tate off waivers from the Baltimore Orioles this year. Tate had limited appearances for Toronto and was not a dependable bullpen option during his time with the Orioles, sporting an ERA closer to 5.00 than 4.00.
To contend for the AL East title and reach the postseason, the Blue Jays need a roster full of competitive pitchers, especially in a division with formidable teams. Below-average pitching can quickly be exposed, and unfortunately, Tate fits that description. Now over 30 and not performing at a level expected of a postseason bullpen arm, the Blue Jays are not committed to him beyond this year. Expect them to let him go in free agency, creating space for a more skilled and promising pitcher.
To compete with the Yankees and Orioles in the AL East, Toronto must field the best talent they can afford.
**2. RHP Erik Swanson**
Erik Swanson finds himself in a situation similar to Dillon Tate, although he may have a bit more leeway. Unlike Tate, whose time with the Blue Jays is likely finished, Swanson has shown competitiveness in 2023, which could earn him a second chance.
In 2023, Swanson recorded a sub-3.00 ERA out of Toronto’s bullpen, following a sub-2.00 ERA in 2022 with the Mariners. His talent is evident, but he failed to perform in 2024, finishing with a 5.26 ERA in 44 appearances, allowing numerous home runs and issuing more walks than usual. While his previous performance could work in his favor, the Blue Jays may still decide to let him go in free agency if his arbitration cost exceeds their budget. With their high expectations, they cannot afford to keep a player in the bullpen who isn’t performing at the elite level, which is why both Swanson and Tate are likely on their way out for 2025.
**1. OF George Springer**
Determining the final player on this list was more challenging. The first two selections—Tate and Swanson—were straightforward due to their poor performances and impending free agency, making them easy cuts. However, George Springer still has nearly $50 million left on his contract over the next two years.
The Blue Jays must find a way to alleviate Springer’s contract burden. Last season, he posted a slash line of .219/.301/.372 with 19 home runs and 19 doubles. While some may see these as respectable numbers, they don’t justify a $24 million annual salary.
Toronto plans to make significant investments in the coming months, including extending Vladimir Guerrero Jr., which will be costly and likely make him the highest-paid player on the team. They are also expected to be active in free agency, pursuing players like Juan Soto or Corbin Burnes, who will demand high salaries.
Every dollar counts this offseason. If the Blue Jays can trade Springer to a lesser team and offload half of his contract, it would greatly benefit their financial situation.
