Tannenbaum’s Myles Garrett Trade Proposal Sparks Heated Debate, RC Walks Off ‘Get Up’ Set
In a bold and somewhat unexpected suggestion, ESPN analyst and former NFL executive Mike Tannenbaum pitched the idea of a blockbuster trade: Myles Garrett, the Cleveland Browns’ star defensive end, to the Detroit Lions. The proposal, shared during ESPN’s *Get Up*, instantly sparked a mix of shock, skepticism, and strong reactions from the show’s panel, ultimately prompting analyst Ryan Clark to walk off the set in a dramatic display of disbelief.
Tannenbaum’s suggestion centered around the idea that the Lions, already showing promise this season, could benefit significantly from Garrett’s elite pass-rushing abilities. Known for his physicality, speed, and game-changing presence on the defensive line, Garrett would theoretically elevate Detroit’s defense to new heights. Tannenbaum argued that the addition of a player like Garrett could transform the Lions into a Super Bowl contender, filling a defensive gap that has held them back in recent seasons.
“Detroit is right on the verge of something special, and with Garrett, they could take that next step,” Tannenbaum insisted. “They have the draft capital, they have young talent, and bringing in a leader like Garrett could change everything.”
But while Tannenbaum was laying out the potential benefits for Detroit, *Get Up* co-host Ryan Clark, a former NFL safety, appeared visibly stunned. Clark interrupted Tannenbaum, challenging the feasibility of such a move, both from a financial and team-building perspective. Clark, an outspoken advocate for player loyalty and team stability, questioned why Cleveland would even entertain trading away their franchise defensive cornerstone, who has been instrumental to the Browns’ recent defensive success.
“You’re talking about trading Myles Garrett like he’s just any other player,” Clark responded. “This guy is the heartbeat of the Browns’ defense. Cleveland is finally building something sustainable, and you want them to throw that away?”
As the back-and-forth intensified, Clark’s frustration became more apparent. He emphatically argued that the Browns wouldn’t, and shouldn’t, consider moving Garrett, as it could disrupt their rebuilding efforts. Tannenbaum countered, stating that the Lions’ assets, combined with the Browns’ needs, could create a mutually beneficial scenario. But the suggestion continued to fall flat for Clark, who finally threw his hands up and walked off the set in mock disbelief.
Fellow *Get Up* host Dan Orlovsky watched with amusement as Clark made his exit but echoed similar concerns about the logistics of such a high-profile trade. Orlovsky noted that while Garrett’s skill would be a game-changer for the Lions, the team has been building a young core and may not want to sacrifice the assets required to land a player of his caliber.
After a few moments, Clark returned to the set, calming down but still shaking his head. The incident highlighted just how polarizing Tannenbaum’s proposal was for the panel, with each analyst viewing the hypothetical trade from differing team philosophies and strategies.
While it’s unlikely that the Browns are actively considering trading Garrett, Tannenbaum’s proposal sparked an engaging debate about the trade value of elite players, team identity, and what it takes to construct a championship roster. For Lions fans, the idea of adding a superstar like Garrett is tantalizing, though the cost may ultimately prove too high for the budding team.
The segment underscored the unpredictable nature of NFL trades and the heated emotions tied to team loyalty and roster building, making for a memorable moment on *Get Up*.
